Policy Suggestion: Enhance Readiness
Enhance readiness for reform of state-owned enterprises
Reform macroeconomic environment
-
Reduce fiscal deficits
Fiscal and monetary reforms that bring revenues and expenditures into
line increase pressure for state-owned enterprise (SOE) reform by making
the burden of SOE deficits explicit
-
Ease trade restrictions
Liberalizing trade restrictions gives exporters a stronger position
in the economy, and exporters can become an important constituency for
SOE reform, demanding more efficient privision of goods and services that
SOE's supply.
-
Remove barriers to entry
Removing barriers to entry increases the number of voices calling for
SOE reform. New entrants who must rely on state-owned enterprise
services or compete with subsidized SOE products help enlarge the constituency
for reform.
-
Initiate financial sector reform
Governments not ready to reform SOE's may still be prepared to develop
their financial system by improving supervisory and regulatory capacity,
reducing directed credit and direct government control over financial intermediaries,
and easing some interest rate controls.
Reduce opposition by workers and others
-
Eliminate obstacles to private job creation
One reason state-owned enterprise workers typically oppose reform is
that while overstaffing makes layoffs likely, appealing alternative employment
is often lacking. Policymakers can thus ease the way for SOE reform
by improving private employment opportunities. Steps include eliminating
interest rate subsidies (these encourage employers to substitute capital
for labor) and complex employment regulations (which have been shown to
inhibit private job growth).
-
Uncouple SOE jobs and social services
State workers who receive many goods and social services through their
jobs are especially fearful of being fired. In most transition economies,
for example, state firms traditionally provided housing, health care, transport,
educational assistance, and other benefits. Creating alternatives
to enterprise benefits, such as a commercial housing market or public health
care, enables SOE's to stop providing these services and offer offsetting
higher pay instead. This gives workers greater mobility and
reduces their resistance to reforms that may threaten their jobs.
Enhance the credibility of government
-
Improve the government's reputation
By announcing reform programs, such as the macroeconomic reforms mentioned
above, in advance and adhering to the program scrupulously, governments
can enhance their reputation with potential reform supporters.
-
Establish domestic and international constraints
Enacting and adhering to constitutional provisions guaranteeing the
right to property can help reassure investors that the government will
honor its commitments. Trade treaties and multilateral agreements
raise the cost of reversing future SOE reforms and help enhance credibility.